tr?id=974648879289261&ev=PageView&noscript=1
 
IT-Enquirer reviews SilverFast 6 Ai
SilverFast 6 Ai Review

SilverFast has a virtual monopoly these days when it comes to supplying scanner software. Less than two years ago, many scanner vendors deemed it necessary to deliver their own feature-rich scanner software with a desktop scanner. More often than not, the software was useless and below standards. Nowadays, only prepress scanners like Imacon's and Creo's come with their own high-brow software bundle. Most mid- to low-end scanners have SilverFast in the box next to a basic TWAIN driver package, and that is a good thing.

SilverFast 6 Ai Calibration is the version that I could test. LaserSoft Imaging is a German software developer of scanner software and software to enter camera data into a computer. SilverFast SE was the version that came with the Epson Expression 4870 that I tested recently. The SE version is feature-limited, however, and Epson does provide its own TWAIN software to control the scanner. That software is good for office use, but is too limited if you are going to use the scanner in a more professional environment, or if you are using the scanner for anything else but basic photograph scanning.

Epson's own software is also good if you are an absolute novice when it comes to scanning and photo-editing. But if you are a bit more skilled, you will very soon find that Epson's bundle does not give you the control you want. SilverFast SE is far better in the area of photo-editing, but lacks a few higher-end features like full 48-bit scanning support or Digital ICE.

LaserSoft Imaging offers an upgrade path to SilverFast Ai, which is the full version, and if you also want to be capable of calibrating your scanner so it fits in an existing workflow, then the Ai with Calibration upgrade is the way to go. The latter comes with two standard Kodak or Fuji targets (one transparent, and one reflective). In the SilverFast online store, you can also buy the much more expensive individually measured targets. This is already one small hint at how high-end SilverFast wants to be.

The Ai software itself comes in different flavours: Windows 2000, XP, etc., and Mac OS X and 9. There is one disadvantage to using SilverFast on Mac OS X: a TWAIN version is not available. This is odd because Mac OS X does support TWAIN, and has done so for some time now. Nevertheless, you are limited to a Photoshop plug-in version with a stand-alone program that depends on the plug-in's presence.

The SilverFast scanning interface

ai-review-gane
SilverFast's interface is easy to use. The tools you will use the most are all easily accessible. A second hint at the professionalism of the package, is the way in which resolution is shown. You can scan a negative at 152 lpi with a Quality Factor of 1 and at 1000%. To see the actual scanning resolution, you must hold down control and it will read "2400 dpi"? (for example). But you can also set your screen and your Q-factor higher, and scan at 2400 dpi again, although you chose to magnify 'only' at 500%. In other words, SilverFast uses the terminology well-known by scanner operators, printers and graphics artists, and calculates the scanning resolution that best fits any output resolution.

SilverFast Ai further supports 48-bit scanning and 48-bit raw scanning. The first is supported only on scanners that support 48-bit colour scanning and the result is a colour-corrected 48-bit image. The 48-bit raw mode switches off all of SilverFast's first-line filtering, i.e. it is identical to what the scanner actually 'sees'. Often the image thus obtained will be very dark and with a heavy colour cast, but it is a method of ensuring you are not filtering the data coming in in any way.

48-bit scanning

ai-review-usm
For most purposes, the regular 48-bit scanning is the best method. SilverFast has quite a few tricks to make sure Photoshop is presented with an image that is already workable in every sense of the word. Some experts will tell you they do all their adjusting and filtering in Photoshop itself, and some will tell you that scanning software is not the best environment to perform any manipulation at all. But SilverFast is quite good at manipulating an image before it gets scanned at full resolution. The reason why you would want to perform adjustments in SilverFast and not in Photoshop, is that you are working on a prescan in SilverFast which is much smaller in terms of memory and therefore faster to handle.

SilverFast GANE

For example, a 3200 dpi scanned image works out to become something like 50 to 200 MB in Photoshop very quickly. That's a lot of data to move around, even if you have a top-of-the-bill Power Mac G5 or a Dell dual Xeon-driven workstation. In SilverFast that prescan file is actually only a fraction of the resulting image. What can you do in SilverFast? The first thing that comes to mind is sharpening. Another option is to apply GANE. GANE is SilverFast's own developed Grain and Noise Elimination algorithm. It works quite well and control over its features is at a granular level. Descreening and USM (unsharp masks) are equally easy and powerful to implement. With descreening and USM, it is only possible to enlarge a photograph to a specific size; anything bigger will make the descreening process useless and therefore is not allowed while you are in SilverFast and the option is selected--a nice mnemonic for those who operate the scanner.

Digital ICE is new to version 6. It removes dust and scratches from negatives without blurring the image. It works by using infrared light to identify physical imperfections in or on the film separately from image detail captured by the emulsion, and then render the detail without the imperfections. On scanners that support Digital ICE (the Epson 4870 and V700 do), SilverFast Ai supports this feature: all you have to do is click the Digital ICE icon and a dialogue window pops up, again offering granular control over the process.

ai-review-scc
Negative scanning

Negatives are SilverFast's strength. NegaFix is available since version 5 and it performs wonders on negatives, provided the scanner has a high enough Dmax setting (dynamic range). For negatives to scan with enough detail, Dmax should be at least 3.6 and preferably somewhere in the 3.8 to 4.x range. Negative scanning is difficult without an aid, and SilverFast provides one: if you know which film was used to shoot the negative (it is actually printed on the negative), you can select your film from a number of drop-down menus giving access to manufacturer and film type. Automatically, the prescan image will be corrected to show you the positive colours instead of the negative ones.

ai-review-dialog
SilverFast Ai 6 is filled to the top with this sort of aids that will help you process an image much faster (and better). Some of the features will make scanning less of a black art, but the fact remains that the first objective is to obtain a perfect image. A good scanner operator will get more out of his scanner with SilverFast than without, and that is more important than making the process easier. Scanner operators have options to correct the photograph before scanning it at full resolution. Changing the colour of the entire image, or changing the colour of part of an image, based on the colours present in the image: these are only two of the many possibilities that SilverFast offers to scan a perfect image. Needless to say, there is an automatic mode as well, which performs a decent job, next to the Levels and Curves that work more or less the same as they do in Photoshop. With the Calibration module present, SilverFast also calibrates the scanner and creates a matching ColorSync (on Macs) or ICC profile.

To wrap up this review, SilverFast Ai 6 is professional-grade scanning software that comes with low-end to mid-end scanners. However, an increasing numbber of so-called low-end scanners are displaying high-end features (the Epson 4870 was the first and is still among the best) for reflective and transparency scanning. To control these scanners at their maximum capabilities, only high-end software will do. SilverFast Ai 6 is such high-end software. The best proof is that a Heidelberg Sapphire scanner can be controlled with the appropriate SilverFast version.

(Source: IT-Enquirer)